BON: THE LAST HIGHWAY, THE OFFICIAL SITE OF AUTHOR JESSE FINK
  • BON: THE BOOK
  • FOREIGN RIGHTS
  • LAID BARE
  • JESSE FINK
  • REMEMBERING BON: THE BLOG

Bon Scott and The Critics

2/1/2018

0 Comments

 
Picture
In doing deep research for Bon: The Last Highway, poring through the archives of yellowed press clippings in various public libraries including the New York Public Library for the Performing Arts, what became immediately apparent to me was that while the media in Australia, the UK and western Europe had fallen under the spell of the talented Australians reasonably early, the mainstream American music press never quite got AC/DC until the 2000s.
Certainly Bon Scott never received the critical kudos he deserved when he was alive. (Today, of course, it is very fashionable to call yourself a Bon fan.)
​AC/DC was variously described, narrowly, as ‘a prototypical heavy-metal band’ with ‘songs that focus on sex, violence, and the occult packaged in live-action album covers’ or ‘blues-based, displaying few of the Baroque influences that strongly affected most heavy metal bands’ or ‘known for crude, rowdy, and sometimes juvenile lyrics that celebrate excess, trangression, and communal bonding, delivered through very hoarse, sometimes screaming, vocals’.
In 1992 Rolling Stone magazine, America’s most powerful music publication, even rated AC/DC’s 1978 masterpiece, Powerage, ★★½ out of a possible five. Mark Coleman was the unfortunate reviewer. Not something he is going to live down quickly.

​
​
But, even so, there were occasional (albeit rare) signals of appreciation of what Bon had contributed to the band and what was missing after his death, even as early as 1980. Billboard, reviewing an AC/DC/Def Leppard double bill in August that year at New York’s Palladium, said Johnson ‘couldn’t quite match Scott’s throttled wail which in the past gave this Australian quintet its menacing edge… without Bon Scott, lead guitarist Angus Young carried the burden of entertaining the crowd.’ Robert Palmer in the New York Times wrote, ‘Mr Scott has been adequately replaced by Brian Johnson’ but added that he ‘looks and sings something like a potential homicidal longshoreman’.
Picture
The band led by Brian Johnson and Angus Young enjoyed AC/DC's greatest success – and critical acknowledgment
Richard Harrington in the Washington Post was similarly underwhelmed: ‘Johnson’s singing style left much to be desired.’
Milwaukee Sentinel’'s Terry Higgins, reviewing Flick of the Switch in 1983, was bang on the money: ‘Every album AC/DC makes with new singer Brian Johnson makes it clear that without the personality and energy of Scott, the band will never be the transcendent experience it once was.’
By the 1990s, the gloves were off for Johnson. Bon had never seemed better. Mike Floyd in the St Louis Post-Dispatch had clearly had enough: ‘How much longer can the world endure the gnarl of vocalist Brian Johnson, who’s never matched up to the late Bon Scott (the guy he replaced in 1980) and who for about 10 erosive years has sounded more and more like an angry squirrel with nut shells stuck in his throat?’ 
Picture

Or this from Michael A. Capozzoli, Jr. in Pennsylvania’s Observer-Reporter in 1996: ‘AC/DC is a prime example of what’s wrong with rock music today. Their work was at one time vital and interesting; they pioneered the hard rock/heavy metal invasion of the mid-’70s. However, when lead singer Bon Scott passed away more than 16 years ago, AC/DC lost their originality.’
In my view, he was right.
‘I like Brian because he always tips his hat to Bon in interviews, and rightfully so, but for singing, Bon had the feel,’ Dennis Dunaway, the original bassist for Alice Cooper, told me during the writing of the book.
Bon had more than the feel. For me, the greatest incarnation of AC/DC died with him on 19 February 1980.
​
BON: THE LAST HIGHWAY: THE UNTOLD STORY OF BON SCOTT AND AC/DC'S BACK IN BLACK is available now.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Jesse Fink is the author of Bon: The Last Highway: The Untold Story of Bon Scott and AC/DC's Back In Black, which is available now. For more information about the book, click HERE or click the book covers below to be directed to editions in your preferred territory and language. 

    Picture
    NORTH AMERICAN EDITION (USA/CAN)
    Picture
    FRENCH EDITION (FRA/CAN)
    Picture
    SWEDISH EDITION
    Picture
    BRAZILIAN EDITION
    Picture
    GERMAN EDITION (GER/AUT/SUI)
    Picture
    AUSTRALIAN EDITION (AUS/NZ)
    Picture
    BRITISH EDITION (UK, IRE)
    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017

    Categories

    All
    1964 (song)
    38 Special
    38 Special (album)
    Accept
    AC/DC
    Adam Bomb
    Adelaide (SA)
    Aerosmith
    Age (newspaper)
    Ahmet Ertegun
    Alan Di Perna
    Alan Rockman
    Alberts
    Albert Studios
    Alcohol
    Alex-young
    Alfred-schacht-publisher
    Alice Cooper
    Alistair Kinnear
    Allentown (PA)
    Allman Brothers
    American Talent International
    A&M Records
    Andrew Paschalidis
    Andy Fraser
    Angus Young
    AOR
    Armageddon (band)
    Artimus Pyle
    Atlantic Records
    Audience (magazine)
    Austin (TX)
    Back In Black (album)
    Back In Black (tour)
    Bad Company
    Barry Bergman
    Bass Player (magazine)
    Bass Players
    Belgium
    Bethel Gospel Assembly
    Bill Bartlett
    Billboard (magazine)
    Bill Church
    Bill Graham
    Biography
    Bishop Carlton T. Brown
    Blackberry Smoke
    Black Oak Arkansas
    Blue Öyster Cult
    Bob Greene
    Bon But Not Forgotten
    Bonfire (album)
    Bon Scott
    Bootlegs
    Brendan O'Brien
    Brian Howe
    Brian Johnson
    Bruce Kapp
    Buffalo (band)
    Buffalo (NY)
    Burnie (TAS)
    Burwood (NSW)
    Buzzcocks
    California
    Carey Gully
    Cassie Gaines
    CBGB (New York)
    Champaign (IL)
    Charlie Daniels
    Charlie Starr
    Cheap Trick
    Chris Squire
    Chrysalis Records
    Chuck Ruff
    Circus (magazine)
    Clarion Records
    Clarissa
    Classic Rock (magazine)
    ClearChannel
    Cliff Williams
    Clinton Walker
    Cocaine
    Concert Footage
    Confederate Battle Flag
    Contraband
    Coral Browning
    Country Rock
    Criteria Recording Studios
    Critical Mass
    Critics
    Dave Evans
    Dave Meniketti
    Davenport (IA)
    David Lee Roth
    David Owen
    Day On The Green
    Daytona Beach (FL)
    Death
    Def Leppard
    Delta-Studio
    Dennis Dunaway
    Detroit (MI)
    Dirk Steffens
    Dirty Eyes
    Donald Trump
    Doreen Reilly
    Doug Thaler
    Down Payment Blues
    Drugs
    Dukes Of Hazzard
    East Dulwich (London)
    Eddie Kramer
    Eddie Van Halen
    Edward B. Marks Music Corporation
    ELO
    Epic Records
    Erie (PA)
    Evie
    Family Jewels (DVD)
    Fayetteville-nc
    Finch
    Flick-of-the-switch-album
    Florida
    Foreigner
    For-those-about-to-rock-tour
    France
    Fraternity
    Free
    Freeway-gardens-motel
    Friday-on-my-mind
    Gabby-darcy
    Gary-pihl
    Gary-richrath
    Gary-rossington
    Georganne-williams
    George-young
    George-young
    Gimme-a-bullet
    Glasgow
    Gone-shootin
    Graeme-smith
    Grahame-harrison
    Grateful-dead
    Green-day
    Hagerstown-md
    Hamish-henry
    Harlem (NY)
    Harry Vanda
    Heart
    Heather Johnson
    Heroin
    High Voltage (album)
    High Voltage (song)
    High Voltage (tour)
    Highway To Hell (album)
    Highway To Hell (song)
    Highway To Hell (tour)
    Hollywood Beach (FL)
    Holly X
    Howard Stern
    Humble Pie
    Ian Baragry
    Ian Jeffery
    If You Want Blood (tour)
    Iggy Pop
    I'm A Rebel (album)
    I'm A Rebel (demo)
    I Put The Finger On You
    Irene Thornton
    Isa Scott
    Jackie Smith
    Jack Orbin
    Jacksonville (FL)
    J. Albert & Son
    James Morley
    Jeff Carlisi
    Jeff Franklin
    Jerry Greenberg
    Jet Set Enterprises
    Jimi Hendrix
    Jimmy Buffett
    Joe Anthony
    Joe Fury
    Joey Alves
    John Ayers
    John D'Arcy
    John Freeman
    Johnny Depp
    Johnny Winter
    Jon Marlowe
    Jon O'Rourke
    Journey
    J.P. Quinton
    Jr.
    Judas Priest
    Julie Browning
    Keith Moon
    Keith Richards
    Ken Schaffer
    Key Biscayne (FL)
    Kid Rock
    Kiss
    Kix
    K.K. Downing
    KMAC/KISS
    Largo (MD)
    Larry Uzzell
    Lee Abrams
    Leon Wilkeson
    Les Gully
    Let It Roll (album)
    Let There Be Rock (album)
    Let There Be Rock (tour)
    Libbi Gorr
    Lights Out (album)
    Linda Blair
    Live From The Atlantic Studios (album)
    Live Wire (book)
    London (England)
    Long Way To The Top (album)
    Loren Molinare
    Los Angeles (CA)
    Lynyrd Skynyrd
    Lyrics
    Mahogany Rush
    Malcolm Dome
    Malcolm Young
    Maria Short
    Marijuana
    Mark Coleman
    Mark Evans
    Mark Opitz
    Mark Putterford
    Martin Huxley
    Mary Renshaw
    Masonic Auditorium (Detroit)
    MCA Records
    Melbourne (VIC)
    Miami
    Miami (FL)
    Miami Herald
    Miami News
    Michael A. Capozzoli
    Michael Anthony
    Michael Browning
    Michael Corcoran
    Michael Fazzolare
    Michael Klenfner
    Michael Schenker
    Michael Stanley Band
    Mick Wall
    Mike Barone
    Mike Floyd
    Mike Fraser
    Milesago.com (website)
    Milwaukee Sentinel
    Mississippi River Jam II
    Mixing
    Molly Hatchet
    Montrose
    Mother's Finest
    Murray Engleheart
    Musicians Studio Rentals
    Musikverlage Oktave
    Mutt Lange
    My Bon Scott (book)
    Nantucket
    Nantucket (album)
    Nazareth
    Neal Mirsky
    Neil Smith
    Newcastle (NSW)
    New Musical Express (magazine)
    New York
    New York City
    New York Public Library For The Performing Arts
    New York Times
    Noel Taylor
    North Dade (FL)
    Nothing To Hide (album)
    Oakland (CA)
    Observer-Reporter (PA)
    Opioid Crisis
    Orlando (FL)
    Outlaws
    Owen Orford
    Pandora
    Pat Pickett
    Pattee Bishop
    Paul Chapman
    Paul Matters
    Paul Raymond
    Performance
    Perry Cooper
    Peter Frampton
    Peter Gabriel
    Peter Head
    Pete Way
    Phil Rudd
    Phil Sutcliffe
    Phoenix (AZ)
    Photographs
    Ponte Vedra Beach (FL)
    Powerage (album)
    Powerage (tour)
    Publishing
    Punk
    Radio
    RAM (magazine)
    Recording
    Record Mirror (newspaper)
    Red Cow (Hammersmith)
    REO Speedwagon
    Richard Harrington
    Richie Teeter
    Rick Derringer
    Rick Keefer
    Rob Bailey
    Robert Palmer
    Robert Valentine
    Rochester (NY)
    Rock 'N' Roll Damnation
    Rolling Stone (magazine)
    Roll With The Changes
    Ronnie Van Zant
    Rose Tattoo
    Rosie
    Round And Round And Round
    Royalties
    Salem (VA)
    Sammy Hagar
    Schaffer-Vega Diversity System
    Schunke Brothers
    Scott Kempner
    Shane Marshall
    Shelby Foote
    Sid Bernstein
    Sidney Drashin
    Silver Smith
    Sink The Pink
    Sirius Satellite Radio
    SiriusXM
    Sounds (magazine)
    Southern Rock
    Sportatorium (Miami)
    Status Quo
    Stefan Kaufmann
    Steve Gaines
    Steven Tyler
    Stevie Wright
    Stevie Young
    St Louis Post-Dispatch
    Sunday Age (Melbourne)
    Sunny Isles (FL)
    Super 8
    Sydney Morning Herald
    Sydney (NSW)
    Sylvie Simmons
    Tasmania
    Teddy Rooney
    Ted Nugent
    Terry Higgins
    Texas
    The Beatles
    The Del-Lords
    The Dictators
    The Dogs
    The Easybeats
    The Haymarket (Sydney)
    The Jack
    The Ken Schaffer Group
    The Kids (band)
    The Music Machine (London)
    The Palladium (New York)
    The Rolling Stones
    The Valentines
    Thin Lizzy
    Tight Squeeze (club)
    TKO
    Tommy Redd
    Tom Petty
    Tony Fasulo
    Towson (MD)
    Tristin Norwell
    Tunc Erim
    TV Shows
    UFO
    Uniondale (NY)
    Van Halen
    Video
    Vince Lovegrove
    Volts (album)
    Vytas Serelis
    WABC (New York)
    Washington (DC)
    Washington Post
    WDIZ Orlando
    West Palm Beach Civic Auditorium
    Whisky A Go Go (Los Angeles)
    Whole Lotta Rosie
    Wilster (Germany)
    WNEW (New York)
    WPDQ/WAIV Jacksonville
    WSHE Miami
    XM Satellite Radio
    Yes
    Yesterday & Today (Y&T)
    YouTube

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • BON: THE BOOK
  • FOREIGN RIGHTS
  • LAID BARE
  • JESSE FINK
  • REMEMBERING BON: THE BLOG
✕